Denlea & Carton

FREE CONSULTATION

May 12, 2025

What to Do After a Rental Car Accident in New York

Exploring New York by rental car opens up endless opportunities, from cruising through vibrant city streets to discovering charming upstate towns. But an unexpected accident can quickly disrupt your plans, leaving you wondering what steps to take next. With varying insurance policies and unique state laws, handling the aftermath of a rental car accident can feel like navigating uncharted territory. At Denlea & Carton, we’re here to help make sense of it all. Our experienced legal team is ready to guide you, protect your rights, and pursue the compensation you deserve. If an accident has interrupted your New York adventure, reach out to Denlea & Carton today for trusted support every step of the way.

Immediate Steps After the Accident

An accident involving a rental car can interrupt your plans, but a quick response can make all the difference. The first priority is making sure everyone involved is safe. While sorting out the immediate aftermath, keep calm and approach the situation step by step. Once you’ve ensured safety, start gathering important information and documenting the scene. This will help immensely when dealing with your claims or legal matters later. 

Follow these key steps:

  • Exchange information with the other driver, including names, insurance details, and contact numbers.
  • Take photos of the accident, covering both vehicles, damage, license plates, and any notable road conditions or signage.
  • Speak to witnesses if there are any, and take down their names and phone numbers. Their input can be valuable if disputes arise.
  • Report the accident to the local police and obtain a copy of the police report for your records.
  • Notify the rental car company and follow their instructions on how to proceed.

By handling these steps carefully, you set yourself up for a smoother process when filing insurance claims or seeking compensation. Preparation and attention to detail can help ensure you’re protected and well-equipped to handle the next steps.

Reporting to the Rental Car Company

After an accident involving a rental car, it’s essential to inform the rental car company as soon as possible. Prompt reporting ensures you’re following their procedures and can help prevent complications down the line. Most rental companies have specific guidelines for documenting the incident and filing claims, so taking the time to understand their process is crucial. They might ask for details like the police report, photos of the damage, or information about the other driver. A dedicated accident attorney can help address any disputes with the rental company’s insurance, advocate for your rights, and ensure all processes are handled fairly, allowing you to focus on what matters most.

Navigating New York Rental Car Insurance Laws

When renting a car in New York, opting for additional rental car insurance may seem like an unnecessary expense, but whether it’s worth it depends on your existing coverage and comfort level. Many personal auto insurance policies or credit cards provide some degree of protection for rental cars. However, these policies might not cover everything, such as “loss of use” charges assessed by the rental company if the car is out of service for repairs. Taking the supplemental coverage offered by the rental company can fill these gaps and provide peace of mind, especially if you’re unsure of your existing policy’s limits. Before declining their insurance, review your personal auto insurance or credit card benefits to ensure you’re adequately covered in the event of an accident.

How Does No-Fault Insurance Work in New York?

New York’s comparative fault laws determine how compensation is divided when more than one party is responsible for an accident. Rather than barring recovery entirely if you share blame, the law adjusts your compensation based on your percentage of fault. This is especially important in rental car accidents, where multiple factors and drivers may come into play. Here’s how it works:

  • Fault is divided by percentage: If you’re deemed 30% at fault, your compensation is reduced by that amount.
  • Shared responsibility is possible: Multiple parties, including rental car drivers, can share the blame for an accident.
  • Evidence shapes outcomes: Documentation like police reports, photos, and witness statements influences the fault determination.
  • Legal representation matters: Having an attorney ensures that fault is assigned fairly and protects you from excessive liability.

By understanding comparative fault, you can better prepare to handle disputes and secure the compensation you deserve, even if you share some responsibility for the accident.

Determining Liability and Who Pays for Damages

When one of their vehicles is involved in an accident, rental car companies are not automatically liable. However, there are scenarios where they can be held responsible. For instance, if a mechanical issue like malfunctioning brakes or poor tire maintenance contributed to the crash, the rental company may be at fault for failing to properly maintain the vehicle. Additionally, if the company allowed an unfit driver to rent the car, for example, someone without a valid license or with a history of DUIs, that negligence could also make them liable. Understanding the nuances of liability in these cases can be vital when seeking compensation.

Here’s a breakdown of who might be liable in a rental car accident:

  • The other driver’s negligence caused the collision.
  • The rental car company claims that improper maintenance or negligence contributed to the accident.
  • A third party, like a pedestrian, cyclist, or another driver, who played a role in the crash.
  • Vehicle manufacturers are liable if a defective part in the rental car led to the accident.

If you’re not at fault for the accident, the other driver’s insurance will typically cover your damages, including vehicle repair costs, medical expenses, and more. It’s crucial to document the incident thoroughly and report it to the rental car company promptly. This helps ensure you’re protected and supported throughout the claims process.

Why You Need a Rental Car Accident Attorney

At Denlea & Carton, we understand the challenges that come with New York’s intricate laws and insurance systems. Our dedicated team brings unmatched experience and a commitment to seeing our clients succeed. We’ll handle every step of your claim from gathering evidence to negotiating aggressively with insurers. You can trust us to prioritize your best interests, so you don’t have to face insurance companies trying to bully you into unfair settlements. With Denlea & Carton, you can feel confident knowing you’ll receive the maximum compensation possible while we fight to protect your rights and manage your claim. Contact Denlea & Carton today to ensure you have the best chance of receiving the compensation and representation you deserve. 

MEET OUR ATTORNEYS

James R. Denlea

Jeffrey I. Carton

Catherine Friesen

Craig Cepler

Steven Schoenfeld

Amber Wallace

Christopher Dennis

Phil Smith

Martin McCann

Lindsey Leibowitz

Robert J. Berg

News & Articles

2 Westchester Park Dr #410
White Plains, NY 10604

Map and Driving Directions

Phone: (914) 331-0100
Email: [email protected]

    Contact Us




    Brooklyn Bar Association logo
    The American Trial Lawyers Association logo
    LCA logo
    American Association for Justice logo
    Best Lawyers 2025