Denlea & Carton

FREE CONSULTATION

July 03, 2025

How Long Does a Car Accident Settlement Take in New York? Understanding the Timelines

After a car accident, one of the first questions many victims have is, “How long does a car accident settlement take in NY?” The answer can vary widely depending on factors like the severity of the injury, the complexity of the case, and how cooperative insurance companies are during negotiations. Understanding these variables is crucial in setting realistic expectations and navigating the settlement process. The attorneys at Denlea & Carton can break down the key aspects that influence settlement timelines and explain how we can help expedite the process while securing maximum compensation.

Why Settlement Timelines Vary Widely

One of the primary reasons car accident settlements take differing amounts of time in New York is the unique circumstances of each case. From minor fender benders to catastrophic collisions, several variables can come into play, including:

  • The extent of the injuries sustained
  • The availability of evidence, such as medical records and police reports
  • Whether liability is clear or disputed
  • Whether the case requires litigation or can be resolved through negotiation

New York’s No-Fault System: Its Impact on Early Stages 

New York operates under a no-fault insurance system, meaning that your insurance company is responsible for covering your medical expenses and lost wages up to a certain amount, regardless of who caused the accident. This can streamline compensation for minor injuries, but it may also delay fault-based claims, especially when injuries exceed the no-fault threshold, such as cases involving severe injury or significant property damage.

Key Factors That Influence Your Settlement Timeline

Several factors determine how long it takes to reach a car accident settlement in NY. Some of the most impactful include:

  • The Severity of Injuries: Cases involving serious injuries often require longer timelines because it’s important to wait until medical treatment is complete to understand the full extent of damages. Settling too early can result in inadequate compensation. 
  • Insurance Negotiations: Cooperation from insurance companies is another variable. Insurers may employ delay tactics to reduce the payout, dragging out the settlement process unnecessarily.
  • Liability and Disputes: If liability is unclear, or fault is shared between parties, investigations may be prolonged as each side gathers evidence to prove their claims.
  • Litigation and Court Schedules: When settlements cannot be reached outside of court, litigation adds complexity and often extends the timeline significantly, as court processes are time-consuming.

The Stages of a Car Accident Settlement Process in New York

To better understand the timeline, it’s helpful to break down the settlement process into key stages:

  1. Initial Investigation and Filing a Claim: Gathering medical records, police reports, and witness statements lays the groundwork for the claim. 
  1. Negotiations with Insurance Companies: The back-and-forth discussions aimed at reaching a settlement can either resolve quickly or extend over months if disputes arise.
  1. Filing Suit if Necessary: If settlement negotiations fail, attorneys may file a lawsuit and begin pre-trial litigation.
  1. Discovery and Evidence Collection: Both parties exchange evidence and depose witnesses, which is often a time-intensive step.
  1. Mediation or Trial: Many cases settle during mediation, but if no agreement is reached, the case proceeds to trial, further extending the timeline.

Typical Settlement Timelines in New York

How long it takes to settle a car crash claim in New York depends greatly on the specifics of your case. Below are general estimates based on case complexity.

Minor Accidents with Clear Liability: Weeks to a Few Months 

For straightforward cases involving minor injuries and no disagreement over fault, settlements can be reached within a few weeks to three months.

Moderate Injuries with Some Disputes: 6 Months to 1 Year 

If medical treatment is still ongoing, or there are small disputes about driving behavior or fault, resolution often takes longer, up to one year.

Serious Injuries or Complex Cases (Including Litigation): 1-3+ Years 

When significant injuries, disputed liability, or the need for court involvement comes into play, a settlement process may take several years to conclude.

How a Personal Injury Attorney Can Help Expedite Your Claim (and Protect Your Rights)

When you’ve been in a car accident, having an experienced personal injury attorney by your side can significantly impact how efficiently and favorably your case is resolved. An attorney possesses the expertise to navigate the complex legal and insurance processes, swiftly identifying and resolving issues that might otherwise delay your claim, such as gathering comprehensive evidence or accurately completing critical paperwork. At Denlea & Carton, our skilled attorneys are adept at accurately valuing your claim, ensuring that all damages—both economic, like medical expenses and lost wages, and non-economic, such as pain and suffering—are thoroughly accounted for in your settlement demand.

Insurance companies often prioritize minimizing payouts, but an attorney will vigorously advocate on your behalf, whether through aggressive negotiations or, if necessary, in court. Crucially, a personal injury attorney ensures compliance with all deadlines, including the statute of limitations. In New York, there is generally a three-year statute of limitations for filing car accident claims. Missing this critical deadline can result in the forfeiture of your right to compensation, making prompt action with legal guidance absolutely essential.

Don’t Wait—Contact Denlea & Carton LLP Today

To help achieve the best outcome as efficiently as possible, turn to the experienced attorneys at Denlea & Carton LLP. We understand the complexities of car accident claims and will work tirelessly to secure the compensation you deserve while protecting your rights every step of the way. Contact us today for a consultation and get the answers—and advocacy—you need during this challenging time.

MEET OUR ATTORNEYS

James R. Denlea

Jeffrey I. Carton

Catherine Friesen

Craig Cepler

Steven Schoenfeld

Amber Wallace

Christopher Dennis

Phil Smith

Martin McCann

Lindsey Leibowitz

Robert J. Berg

John Kane

News & Articles

2 Westchester Park Dr #410
White Plains, NY 10604

Map and Driving Directions

Phone: (914) 331-0100
Email: [email protected]

    Contact Us





    Brooklyn Bar Association logo
    The American Trial Lawyers Association logo
    LCA logo
    American Association for Justice logo
    Best Lawyers 2025